“The notion that small businesses will join a PRPP because it’s simpler than existing employee-sponsored options is a bit of pipedream.”
Toronto (17 January 2011) – The introduction of the new Pooled Retirement Pension Plan (PRPP) will do little to fill the gap in retirement income, Paul Forestell, a senior partner at Mercer consulting, told a crowd of investment managers in Toronto last Thursday.
In the private sector, 75% of companies offer no pension plan at all and only 38% of Canadians contributed to a RRSP in 2009, according to Statistics Canada.
In December, federal Finance Minister Jim Flaherty announced he was moving ahead with the PRPPs. The plans will offer defined contributions administered by a third party, probably a financial institution. The savings vehicle is supposed to be relatively low-cost because of its sheer size and simplicity.
“It sounds great and if implemented will be a positive step for retirement savings in Canada but probably just a very small step”, Forestell said.
“The notion that small businesses will join a PRPP because it’s simpler than existing employee-sponsored options is a bit of pipedream”, he suggested.
“I’m not certain that this will be enough incentive for employers who do not currently provide any retirement savings options to join a pooled RPP.”
That’s because many of the defining characteristics of the PRPP can also be attributed to the typical RRSP or the tax-free savings account and many small business owners simply don’t have the time or money to offer such a plan.
Those who already offer group RRSP or a defined contribution pension plan may opt to switch to a PRPP and that could dilute retirement income of plan members.
Under the new regulation, provinces can choose to mandate PRPP automatic enrollment for small businesses and the self-employed but that’s unlikely to happen, Forestell said, since setting base line contribution level would be nothing short of a nightmare.
If it’s too low, the plan won’t do much to address the funding gap. It it’s too high, employees are more likely to withdraw from the program.
“It’s starting to sound a lot like the story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears. You need to set a contribution plan ‘just right’ to make a mandatory plan work.”
The “just-right” contribution level of course depends on age, income, retirement needs and other factors.
Pension reform will remain atop of the agenda in 2011, 2012 and beyond, Forestell said
The National Union of Public and General Employees (NUPGE) is one of Canada's largest labour organizations with over 340,000 members. Our mission is to improve the lives of working families and to build a stronger Canada by ensuring our common wealth is used for the common good. NUPGE