President's Commentary: The top ten reasons to expand the Canada Pension Plan | National Union of Public and General Employees

President's Commentary: The top ten reasons to expand the Canada Pension Plan

CPP is the envy of the world: it’s secure, funded on a sound basis and well managed by professional staff independent of government.

By James Clancy
National President
National Union of Public and General Employees (NUPGE)

Ottawa (27 Oct. 2010) – Canada is facing a retirement income crisis as more and more Canadians are about to enter their retirement years without adequate income security.

We need to collectively fix this problem facing our nation. We know we cannot rely on the private sector to do so, as they have failed miserably in providing Canadians with decent retirement income. Close to 11 million Canadian workers do not have a private pension plan. These workers must rely on their own individual savings, through contributions to risky RRSPs or other means, for their retirement security.

It’s obvious this approach is not working for most Canadians and the situation is going to get worse if we don’t take action now.

The solution lies within the Canada Pension Plan (CPP). Our CPP is the envy of the world: it’s secure, funded on a sound basis and well managed by professional staff independent of government. The only problem with CPP is that benefit levels are way too low to provide Canadians with adequate income security in their retirement.

The best solution to providing Canadians with adequate income in retirement is to expand CPP.

Here are ten excellent reasons why:

1. CPP already covers virtually all Canadian workers

CPP is a national, public, universal workplace pension plan funded exclusively by contributions made by employees and employers at no cost to government. It covers 93% of Canadian workers, whether employed or self-employed, full-time or part-time.

2. CPP offers a guaranteed income to all Canadian retirees

CPP guarantees retirees ongoing certainty with respect to their benefit entitlements. As a national, mandatory defined benefit pension plan, CPP guarantees all Canadian workers a monthly benefit when they retire related to the income they earned during their working lives.

3. CPP provides a number of benefits in addition to a monthly pension

While it is perhaps best known for its retirement pensions, CPP offers many extra benefits that are not available in any other workplace pensions. Additional benefits include disability, death, survivor and children’s benefits. CPP administers the largest long-term disability plan in Canada.

4. CPP is the most portable pension plan in Canada

One of the greatest advantages of this national plan is the continuity of pension coverage it provides employees who change jobs. CPP is fully portable when employees move from job to job across provinces and territories. Because of its more universal and mandatory nature, CPP provides the best continuity of benefits of any pension plan in Canada.

5. CPP benefits rates are increased annually to the rate of inflation

CPP benefits are increased each January based on the annual Consumer Price Index (CPI). These increases are legislated under the Canada Pension Plan Act to ensure that benefits keep up with the cost of living. Even if there are decreases in the cost of living, CPP benefit rates do not decrease. By example, since October 2004, the CPI has increased by 9% while CPP rates increased by 12%.

6. CPP compensates employees for periods of low earnings

Unlike any other pension plan, CPP accommodates different work patterns of parents, other care givers and those with periods of work interruptions. Women especially find the CPP child-rearing drop-out provision helpful since it allows employees to drop up to seven years of low or zero earnings due to child rearing from the calculation of their future benefits (this will increase to eight years by 2012). No other plan allows for this consideration.

7. CPP provides Canadians with a risk free investment

CPP is recognized as one of the most stable plans in the world. It is also one of the largest and fastest-growing pools of assets anywhere in the world. With the built-in expertise of its professional investment managers and strong public sector accountability, CPP significantly reduces risk for employees and employers. It also spreads the risk across generations by pooling life expectancy and investment risk among all contributors and beneficiaries.

8. CPP is well managed with low administration costs

CPP is administered by a professional investment management organization that operates at arm’s length from governments. The investment management costs of CPP are shared by all Canadians so less of the fund is taken up by fees. Only 1.1% of CPP assets are used to manage the fund and these fees are expected to decrease with the growth of the fund. When compared to the high management and broker fees charged by the financial services industry to sell risky RRSPs, the low CPP fees allow Canadians to keep hundreds of dollars more of their monthly retirement income.

9. CPP is secure, stable and sustainable for generations to come

Canada’s Chief Actuary stated in his latest report that the CPP fund is sustainable for at least the next 75 years. Despite even the recent unprecedented market downturn, the CPP fund is expected to deliver the returns required to help sustain the plan for decades and generations. Not one cent of the CPP’s current $130 billion investment portfolio is being used to help pay for pensions today because current contributions more than cover benefits being paid out. It will be at least another 10 years before even a small portion of CPP’s investment income will be needed to help pay for pensions. Beyond that time, CPP will continue to grow for decades to come.

10. CPP plays a significant role in Canada’s economy

Contrary to some misconceptions, CPP benefits are not paid from government revenues. It’s totally funded by contributions from employees, employers and the self-employed in the paid workforce. CPP actually generates more revenues than it pays out in benefits and therefore, contributes to the overall growth of the Canadian economy. In 2009, four million Canadians received $29 billion in benefits. CPP also plays a major role in investing in Canada’s economy with 46% of its investment fund (or $60 billion) invested in Canadian companies and infrastructure.

Expanding CPP will go a long way to improve the financial security of Canadian seniors.

Like all public programs and services, CPP is an important tie that binds us together as a nation. It is an expression of our collective commitment to one another and to the fundamental principle that all citizens have the right to income security and dignity.

We must seize the opportunity that exists today and demand that our political leaders across the country embrace this most sensible, affordable and effective approach to improving retirement security for all Canadians.


James Clancy
National President


James Clancy is the national president of the National Union of Public and General Employees (NUPGE), one of Canada's largest labour organizations with over 340,000 members. Our mission is to improve the lives of working families and to build a stronger Canada by ensuring our common wealth is used for the common good. NUPGE




Issues and Campaigns: